The Original Sin Podcast Episodes

 In August 2022, Corey Shearer was murdered. Corey was shot and killed at a house party in Rancho Cordova after a few minutes on the property. 

Then, years later, the Sacramento County Sheriff’s Office arrested the then-19-year-old Amyis Coogler for Corey’s murder. The night of the shooting, Coogler was only 17 years old, but he was caught on a neighbor's surveillance camera fleeing after the 2022 shooting. Why did Coogler do it? 

Bianca Carrasco, a 29-year-old nurse and mother of three from San Antonio, Texas, vanished on May 1, 2016, after an argument with her husband. She was last seen walking away from their home, reportedly upset, and has not been heard from since. Despite extensive searches and public appeals, no trace of Bianca has been found, and her case remains unsolved, leaving her family desperate for answers and justice. 

Brenda Lambert, a 22-year-old mother from Bluewell, West Virginia, vanished on July 26, 1992, just after her son’s first birthday celebration. Her car, purse, and shoes were found abandoned, suggesting she never left willingly. Despite immediate concern and years of searching, no solid leads have ever emerged.

In this podcast, we revisit Brenda’s final known moments, explore theories surrounding her disappearance, and highlight why her case remains unsolved more than 30 years later. Her family continues to seek answers — and someone out there still knows the truth.

 

Amber Spradlin was found brutally stabbed inside a dentist’s home in Floyd County, Kentucky — a discovery that shook a quiet Appalachian community to its core. With the dentist’s son charged with murder and others accused of destroying evidence, questions remain, DNA waits in processing, and justice feels painfully out of reach. On this episode, we revisit Amber’s final hours, the alleged cover-up, and the long road still ahead for truth and accountability.

On September 4, 2023, 19-year-old Noah Presgrove was found dead along Highway 81 in Jefferson County, Oklahoma — naked except for two mismatched shoes, his body covered in blunt-force injuries no one can fully explain. Officially, his death remains “undetermined,” but his family believes the truth is far more sinister, alleging he was beaten to death after a night of partying and that those involved helped bury the truth instead of his memory. As accusations rise, friends deny involvement, and the investigation stalls, one question grows louder than all the rest: What really happened to Noah? 

She was only three months old when she vanished without a trace.

On the night of September 11, 2018, baby Arieanna Day disappeared from her crib inside a home in Roanoke. There were no signs of forced entry, no witnesses, and no body has ever been found. She was last seen wearing a pink onesie and socks.

In the years that followed, Arieanna’s father was charged with concealing a body, while her mother publicly named a person of interest. Yet despite arrests, accusations, and shifting narratives, Arieanna has never been recovered—and no one has been held accountable for what happened that night.

On August 6, 1989, Elisa Roberson, a 13-year-old girl from Aransas Pass, Texas, disappeared after leaving her home to meet a friend at a predetermined midpoint. She never arrived — and no confirmed sightings, physical evidence, or answers have ever emerged. What should have been a short, ordinary walk became a mystery that has haunted her family and community for more than three decades

In this episode of The Original Sin Podcast, we examine the timeline of Elisa Roberson’s disappearance, what investigators know, and the critical questions that remain unanswered. We also explore how missing-children cases were handled in the late 1980s and why renewed public attention is essential for long-unsolved cases like Elisa’s.